A 433-A needs income and expense figures that tie to the client's bank records, not to memory. When there are no books, the practical path is to pull every business and personal account statement for the look-back period, categorize each deposit and withdrawal, separate business from personal, and produce a profit and loss the Revenue Officer can trace back to the bank.
That package is what book reconstruction for tax professionals is for. You present the numbers. We do not call the IRS.
What does the 433-A actually ask for on the business side?
Form 433-A is the collection information statement for wage earners and self-employed individuals. Publication 1854 is the IRS guide to preparing it. On the business side it asks for income and expenses of the activity the person runs. The IRS then compares what the form says to what the bank shows.
That comparison is where unsupported numbers fall apart. A round monthly sales figure that never appears as deposits will not survive a request for statements. A pile of "expenses" that are owner draws, loan payments, or transfers will not survive it either.
Collection Financial Standards govern allowable living expenses. They are not a substitute for business records. Business income and business expenses come from the accounts. The published living-expense amounts change, and that table is not the business profit and loss.
The Financial Analysis Handbook is the internal guide Revenue Officers use when they test a collection statement. You do not need to recite it. You need a file that still holds up when someone does.
Why "the client will send a summary" fails
Client estimates are almost always low on income and high on expenses. People remember the rent and the vendor they argued with. They forget the deposits that were "just a transfer" and the card that paid for both the job and the groceries.
A Revenue Officer can request the underlying statements at any time. If the numbers do not tie, the practitioner's credibility takes the hit, not the client's. The client already told the Service the books were a mess. You are the one who signed the form.
I would rather see a gap report that says "March has no statement" than a neat profit and loss with a number plugged in to make the year look finished. What a preparer needs from behind books is the same standard: support, not a story.
How do you build a profit and loss from bank statements alone?
This is the sequence I use when the file starts as a stack of PDFs.
- Inventory every account: business checking, personal checking used for the business, credit cards, PayPal, Square, Venmo, Stripe, and any cash-app account that took a customer payment.
- Get statements for the full period. Banks typically keep about seven years. A closed account can still be requested in writing inside that window.
- Classify every deposit: sales, transfers between the client's own accounts, loans, owner contributions, refunds. Transfers counted as income are the most common overstatement.
- Classify every withdrawal: business expense, owner draw, personal spending, loan payment. Personal spending is not a business expense because it left the business account.
- Reconcile each account month by month so the ending balance ties to the statement. If it does not, the classification is not done.
- Produce the profit and loss and a gap report for anything that cannot be supported.
Reconstructing books from bank statements is the longer version of that sequence. Missing records and gap reports is how the holes get written down instead of filled in.
What do you do with cash income and missing months?
Be honest in the gap report. Do not plug numbers.
Cash that never hit a bank cannot be invented from a statement. If the client says there was cash income, the gap report says so, names the months, and stops. The practitioner decides what, if anything, goes on the form. That is representation. It is not bookkeeping.
The IRS has its own indirect methods for testing income, including a bank-deposits analysis described in IRM 4.10.4. Clean books built from statements should anticipate that analysis. Deposits explained as transfers, loans, or owner contributions need a schedule, because those are the deposits someone will ask about.
How should the finished package look to a Revenue Officer?
| Deliverable | What it proves |
|---|---|
| Profit and loss by month, for each year in the look-back | Income and expenses, in the periods the form covers |
| Account reconciliations | Ending balances match the statements |
| Transfer schedule | Money that moved between the client's accounts was not counted twice |
| Owner draw schedule | Personal spending and draws are not sitting in expenses |
| Gap report | What cannot be supported is named, not filled in |
| Categorization notes | Why a line was called sales, a draw, or an expense |
Sample deliverables show the shape of a monthly package. A 433-A file is that shape, tied to the look-back, plus the schedules above. Owner draws and personal cards is the schedule I will not skip on a mixed account.
Which deposits get called income when they are not?
This is the part I recheck on every file, because it is where a neat profit and loss quietly overstates the business.
A transfer between the client's own accounts is not sales. If the business checking receives money from the personal checking, that is the owner moving cash, not a customer. Count it once, on the transfer schedule, or you will tax a dollar that was already counted when it first arrived.
A loan deposit is not sales. The deposit is large, round, and often matches a note the client forgot they signed. The payments that follow are not automatically expenses either. Principal is a balance sheet item. Interest may be an expense. Split them if the statement lets you. If it does not, say so.
A refund from a vendor is not sales. It reduces the expense or comes back as other income, depending on what was originally booked. A processor deposit is usually net of fees. The gross receipts live in the processor report, not in the smaller amount that hit the bank.
Owner draws are the reverse mistake. Money that left for personal rent, groceries, or a personal card payment is not a business expense because it came out of the business account. It belongs on the draw schedule. Owner draws and personal cards is the version of that schedule I expect to see before a 433-A goes out.
If a line can be two things, the categorization note picks one and says why. A Revenue Officer does not need your doubt. They need the reason, next to the amount, so the comparison to the statement is boring.
Where we fit and where we stop
We rebuild the books from the statements. A licensed CPA reviews the file before it goes out. We never contact the IRS, never file a return, and never represent the client. The firm presents the numbers.
If the file is the one you do not want to staff, start at book reconstruction for tax professionals. A $500 diagnostic is a read-only review of the records you already have. You get findings with dollar amounts and a fixed quote. The $500 credits toward the work. Nothing is produced until you accept that quote in writing. Pricing is the short version.
Frequently asked questions
Can a 433-A be submitted without bookkeeping records?
The form can be filled in from the client's memory. Figures that do not tie to bank records invite a request for the statements and can stall the case. A profit and loss that traces back to the accounts is the version a Revenue Officer can test.
How many months of bank statements does the IRS want with a 433-A?
Read the current Form 433-A instructions. The look-back the form asks for changes with those instructions. Pull the statements they name, plus any account the business actually used.
Does the IRS accept a profit and loss prepared from bank statements?
Comparing stated income to bank deposits is how the IRS tests the numbers. A profit and loss built from those same statements is the most defensible version, because the comparison has already been done.
What if the client mixed business and personal spending in one account?
Separate it line by line. Sales stay income. Transfers between the client's own accounts do not. Personal spending and owner draws come out of expenses and get their own schedule. Mixed accounts are common. Hidden ones are the problem.
Who prepares the financials, the practitioner or a bookkeeper?
Either. Many firms keep the case and hand off the rebuild so staff stay on representation. We rebuild the books. We never contact the IRS, file a return, or represent the client.